Rebecca is crushing on her new stepbrother, Pres. Celeste, her friend, tells her that Pres could feel differently, but Rebecca ignores the advice. Celeste's brother, Josh, who is also friends with Pres, volunteers to help Rebeccca with a school project, and Rebecca comes to depend on his help more than she realizes.
Rebecca also struggles to find a way to connect with her new stepfather. Through several twists and turns, Rebecca learns that perfect is not necessarily what she first thought.